Home Legal Advice A Step within the Right Direction?: Critical Analysis of Maternity Benefits as...

A Step within the Right Direction?: Critical Analysis of Maternity Benefits as under guarantee under the Social Security Code, 2020 in India



Unorganised Sector has been, in entirety, outlined in “Report on Conditions of Work and Promotion of Livelihoods in the Unorganised Sector, September 2007”[1] by the National Commission for Enterprises within the Unorganised Sector (NCEUS) as, “the unorganised sector consists of all unincorporated private enterprises owned by individuals or households engaged in the sale and production of goods and services operated on a proprietary or partnership basis and with less than ten total workers”.

Generally, the phrases “unorganised sector” and “informal sector” are used interchangeably.

There has been the absence of dependable statistics on the dimensions, distribution or contribution to the economic system, the unorganized sector has all the time remained a poorly understood and grossly uncared for space. According to the report of the Economic Survey let go in 2019, the unorganized sector accounts for 93% of the full workforce of the nation.[2]

The ‘Report of the Committee on Unorganised Sector Statistics’ of the National Statistical Commission (NSC), 2012 states that the casual sector constitutes 93% of the general workforce and contributes 50% in the direction of the Gross National Product (GNP)[3].

It is a well-known proven fact that the unorganized sector has an enormous hand in operating the nation’s economic system, but there has not been concrete provision to guard it from time immemorial and but, such a big workforce lacks clear authorized protections.

In pursuance of the need, the laws got here up with the Social Security Code with an goal of consolidating all social safety legal guidelines (that are already carried out) with a view to offering social safety to all staff and staff, both in organised or unorganised sectors, gig staff and platform staff.

The analysis goals to analyse the provisions and guidelines of maternity advantages as under guarantee under the Social Security Code, 2020 in India.

Need Due to the Disruption

The necessity to guard the maternity rights of feminine staff was recognised by the laws a very long time again. The legal guidelines associated with maternity advantages have been launched with the goal to control the employment of girls at sure durations (earlier than and after childbirth).

It was first launched in 1961; the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961. The goal of the Act was: “to regulate the employment of women in certain establishments for certain periods before and after child-birth and to provide for maternity benefit and certain other benefits.”

Stand of Protection of Maternity Benefits recognised in International Customary Law and Convention

Article 23 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948[4] states that

  1. “Everyone has the right to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favourable conditions of work and to protection against unemployment.
  2. Everyone, without any discrimination, has the right to equal pay for equal work.
  3. Everyone who works has the right to just and favourable remuneration ensuring for himself and his family an existence worthy of human dignity, and supplemented, if necessary, by other means of social protection.
  4. Everyone has the right to form and to join trade unions for the protection of his interests.”

The mentioned customary legislation not directly infers the need of offering such advantages and thereto defending them additional.

On the Global entrance, the standardised laws relating to maternity advantages have been established under the Maternity Protection Convention, 2000 (No. 183) after the alternative of its first Maternity Protection Convention in 1919 (No. 3) and Maternity Protection on the Workplace, 1952 (No. 103) and in addition the adoption of Maternity Protection Recommendation, 2000 (No. 191). Also, in the course of the 92nd International Labour Conference in 2004, International Labour Organisation member states adopted resolutions applicable to extending maternity safety entry and selling work-life stability in its entirety. India is a founding member of ILO.

Stand under the Constitution of India

Article 42 of the Constitution of India accommodates the directive that the State shall make provision for securing simply and humane circumstances of labor and maternity advantages.

Furthermore, on comparative strains, in an effort to regulate the employment of girls in sure institutions for particular durations earlier than and after childbirth and to accommodate for maternity advantages and sure different advantages, the Indian Parliament enacted the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961. The Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 was enacted conserving in view not solely all these legislations associated with maternity that existed from the pre-Constitution days, but additionally ILO’s mandate relating to maternity safety (ILO Maternity Protection Convention, 1952- No. 103).

Is Objective getting Fulfilled?

The Code on Social Security, 2020 has been handed by each Houses and has already obtained Presidential assent on September 28, 2020, however it’s but to be carried out.

As we have now recognized, the principle goal of the introduction of the Social Security Code, 2020 was to consolidate legal guidelines to all staff, however the main query which arises is whether or not the maternity pursuits of the feminine staff are getting protected or not.

Hence, for a similar let’s analyse the provisions of the Code associated with Maternity Benefits.

Chapter VI of the Code 2020 recognises the side of Maternity Benefits.

The Code has been proposed with an intention to subsume a number of of the Central Labour Law Acts under the garb of ‘simplifying and rationalising’ the mentioned provisions.

The very well intention behind the consolidation of legal guidelines into the self-contained and exhaustive Code on Social Security is extending the ambit and growth of welfare to the employees fraternity.

But when inspecting the provisions set under the Code associated with maternity advantages set out under Chapter VI of the Code, the intention can’t be wholly coated.

Maternity Benefits- Not mere a Legal Responsibility however a Social Responsibility

Providing maternity advantages to each girl employee is the paramount social accountability of the federal government and the employer. But it’s fairly evident in India that the beneficent maternity advantages grant advantages to simply 1% of the ladies staff as an entire. Ensuring maternity advantages is a common cry. This is crucial to make sure the upliftment and empowerment of girls and gender equality. The 98th International Labour Conference held in June 2009 even acknowledged that the strengthening of maternity safety is the important thing to gender equality at office, while conserving in thoughts the appliance of ILO Convention on Maternity Protection (No. 183) which promotes and provides utmost precedence to equality of all girls within the workforce and the well being and security of the mama and youngster.

The Missing Aspects: Analysis of Chapter VI of the Code and in furtherance Recommendations

The authorities appears to have ignored the advice of the Sixth Central Pay Commission[5] and has ignored a majority of the workforce that works within the unorganized sector; together with labourers from the agriculture sector, seasonal staff, home staff or development staff.

With over 90% of working girls class within the casual sector, solely few of them are even throughout the purview of the Act. While the Unorganised Workers’ Social Security Act, handed in 2008, consists of maternity advantages as one of many entitlements for the unorganised, no wage-linked scheme for such goal has but been notified by the Government. The Janani Suraksha Yojana has been notified under this Act, however the identical is a mere incentive for institutional supply and nothing extra.

The solely entitlement at present out there for all girls is specified under the National Food Security Act, which guarantees a advantage of drawing Rs. 6,000 to all pregnant and lactating girls. In the Code, there is no such thing as a such mentioning of the sufferings of the casual sector girls faces because of an implicit excessive workload, leading to a rise of circumstances of sickness and possibilities of miscarriage.

The Code even fails to universalise the ambit of fee of maternity profit. Until and except maternity advantages are universalized by the use of the suitable provision within the Code, a majority of girls who work within the casual sector could be excluded from its purview. Hence, it is suggested that requisite amendments needs to be made to present common protection of maternity advantages to all girls staff together with these working within the unorganised/casual sector.

Payment of maternity advantages to each girl employee needs to be ensured. The present Maternity Benefit Act is kind of a beneficent one. This could also be amended to include all the ladies staff together with the agricultural staff. But subsuming the Act within the Code, the Code doesn’t spell out something clearly. The Code ought to incorporate infrastructure, institutional mechanism and budgetary allocation to make sure the fulfilment of social dedication.

The Code additionally appears to overlook out the chance to introduce paternity go away and probably an opportunity to unfold the message that the accountability of operating a household unit needs to be of each the dad and mom.

Clause 22 of the European Union (Directive of European Parliament, 2019) specifies the necessity for maternity, paternity and parental advantages in case of a social safety system opted by the institutions.[6]

Countries such because the United Kingdom, Singapore, Sweden and Australia have realised the necessity of the hour and thereby launched numerous different classes of leaves regarding childbirth, like parental go away, household unit go away and so forth. in an effort to present the go away advantages to each dad and mom, and thereby serving to them to have a stability between their careers and private life and in addition making certain that the kid’s correct care and a focus from each the dad and mom in his/her preliminary years of improvement. Although the steps taken by the federal government are commendable, the federal government has missed out this chance to meet up with such necessities. Hence, under Clause 60 of the Code, it is suggested that paternity go away as per the rules must also be included within the provision.

Appropriate provisions needs to be included within the Code to make sure six months paid go away to each girl employee for childbirth. For the ladies of the unorganised sector what place there are a number of employers; the federal government, central or state, because the case could also be, ought to make funds equal to such wage fee within the respective business by way of the unorganised sector welfare board. And in States, what place there aren’t any boards, the fee needs to be made by way of the Ministry of Labour.

In most of nations, the fee associated with offering such advantages is solely borne by the federal government and/or shared by each authorities and employer as per the social safety schemes offered. But it isn’t the case in India, what place the wages in the course of the maternity leaves are borne by the employer solely (with a mere exception under the ESI Act). There can also be a requirement of getting a crèche facility, and so forth., which might, in flip, require employers to ascertain ample infrastructure thus prompting extra inquiries and extra bills. Hence, there’s want of an specific provision citing the laws relating to the bearer of such bills, shared by each authorities and employer. Or explicitly point out the allowance of shared crèche with different institutions, what place sustaining a separate crèche wouldn’t be practicable or economically possible for the employer.

The Code under Clause 59 (3) does prohibit “work of arduous nature” finished by any girl in the course of the prescribed interval earlier than the date of highly anticipated supply. But the identical has not been outlined, as to what’s thought-about under the ambit of “work of arduous nature”.

Hence, there’s a want for a selected and unambiguous definition of “work of arduous nature” in an effort to set up “arduousness” in order that employers might be held accountable for danger work as girls staff particularly within the casual sector are sometimes engaged in hazardous and dangerous types of work and in addition in an effort to guarantee its correct and uniform interpretation within the Code.



Definitely, adoption of such advantages is a boon to society.

But any Law enforceable has grow to be significant solely by way of its efficient enforcement and notably, in case of labour legal guidelines, periodic inspection and/or inspection on receipt of grievance is the life line of enforcement. The efficient utility of the applicable provision by way of the system of labour inspection has been surpassed on this Code. Hence, all the approach is to make the legislation effectively enforceable in an effort to shield the employees’ pursuits.


[1] https://msme.gov.in/sites/default/recordsdata/Condition_of_workers_sep_2007.pdf

[2] https://pib.gov.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=191213


[4] https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-human-rights

[5] https://doe.gov.in/sites/default/recordsdata/6cpchighlights%281%29%281%29.pdf

[6] https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32019L1152&rid=3


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here