Home Criminal Defense New PBS documentary exhibits how one man’s legacy modified the trajectory of...

New PBS documentary exhibits how one man’s legacy modified the trajectory of American race relations


Individuals and corporations reach out to me recurrently relating to their new law-related TV tasks. Recently, I acquired an electronic mail relating to the brand new PBS documentary The Blinding of Isaac Woodard, which first aired March 30. I used to be despatched a link to a press preview that gave entry to the manufacturing previous to its launch.

I used to be not very aware of the topic’s identify. I do know PBS is a exceptional community with a variety of instructional thing at its disposal, however I didn’t know the person behind the documentary’s title. Before deciding whether or not to commit myself to this system’s almost two-hour runtime, I made a decision to do some analysis.

A fast internet question for the documentary’s title initially introduced up the Woody Guthrie tune by the identical identify. Seeing how Guthrie and that I are each Oklahoma born and bred, but I used to be nonetheless unfamiliar with the plight of Isaac Woodard, I made a decision I’d learn the tune’s lyrics and go from there.

A person on a bus

Guthrie’s tune tells Woodard’s story from the first-person perspective: He was an African American Army veteran who, instantly after getting back from World War II, was brutally crushed, blinded and arrested by white Southern regulation enforcement officers after receiving his discharge from the service—all whereas carrying his U.S. Army uniform with service-related awards, together with a battle star from the Asiatic-Pacific Campaign Medal.

The lyrics piqued my interest. I started viewing the documentary, and that I’m glad I did. As is usually the case with lots of PBS’s merchandise, substance is most well-liked over model. The presentation probably gained through a win’t preserve the eye of right this moment’s frenetic viewing viewers who always crave the lower scenes and in-court footage that’s the hallmark of true crime’s most up-to-date iterations.

Hopefully viewers will nonetheless be taken in by this documentary, as they’d miss out on a really well-crafted broadcast in any other case, because the documentary will enthrall anybody aware of the final model of PBS’s wares. The in depth use of historic imagery within the type of images and newspaper clippings provides the documentary a Ken Burns vibe that hits its desired mark most of the time.

The Blinding of Isaac Woodard begins proper what place the rubber hits the highway, beginning much akin to the Woody Guthrie synopsis cited above. Individuals fascinated by the true crime style’s inner-workings (together with its origins and present-day type) will probably be inquisitive about discovering how Woodard’s story gained an excessive stage of nationwide appeal relative to its day and age.

Orson Welles brings the nationwide highlight

I famous the documentary begins by introducing Woodard to the viewers; nonetheless, that introduction isn’t merely left to the first-rate voiceover expertise of the presentation’s narrator. No, the opening comes courtesy of an unmistakably timeless voice. Right out of the gate, the viewers is treated to the tones of the one and solely Orson Welles.

Without much background information and absolutely conscious Welles has been deceased for over 35 years, my ears perked as I spotted this story have to be one thing momentous to garner not solely a Woody Guthrie tune but in addition an Orson Welles rendition of Woodard’s affidavit. As the documentary continued, I grew to grasp extra about Welles’ involvement.

Once Woodard’s maiming was reported, the NAACP turned intertwined. The prejudice and violence Woodard skilled was not remote. In 1946, the NAACP had its hands full with circumstances involving racial discrimination and violence in opposition to Black servicemen returning dwelling from the battle.

The documentary does glorious work explaining the underlying motive: As these battle heroes returned dwelling of their uniforms, they inevitably struck concern within the ignorant minds of many Southerners. Racists relied on African Americans to “know their place” by means of concern of hazard and demise.

However, these Black servicemen had simply confronted each—and gained through a win. They returned from combating a battle in opposition to a fascist regime that had steamrolled by means of Europe on the again of a platform primarily based on the notion that some races of males had been lower than others.

Surely, after defeating the enemy and the related mindset, they might return dwelling to a greater place, proper? Wrong.

Racial violence surged in 1946, and Woodard’s state of affairs was sadly one among many. Nevertheless, the very fact this man had been blinded by white officers of the regulation—whereas carrying his Army uniform and the emblems of his sacrifice—struck a definite chord. The NAACP needed to get as much publicity as attainable for Woodard’s trigger, in order that they reached out to Welles. Isaac Woodard’s assailant had not but stepped ahead, and the hope was to find who had dedicated these crimes and in what jurisdiction.

At the time, Welles had a radio show broadcast nationally each week. Whether it was his hatred of racial inequality, or extra so his love of a superb “whodunnit,” Welles devoted 5 weeks to Woodard’s story, holding his viewers engaged by pressuring “Officer X” to point out himself and come clean with his deed.

Welles even went as far as hiring a personal investigator to comply with the bus route Woodard traveled after being honorably discharged to find out to which jurisdiction the officer belonged. He threatened that “Officer X” was going to be uncovered, and that’s exactly what occurred.

The seeds of desegregation

Once the officer was recognized, civil rights teams throughout the nation started writing letters demanding prosecution of the now-known attacker. Those calls for initially fell on deaf ears till NAACP Executive Secretary Walter White reached out to President Harry S. Truman, pleading for the Department of Justice to prosecute the person chargeable for beating and maiming Woodard.

President Truman was initially hesitant. Yet, his background as a deployed WWI veteran himself, and the internalization that Woodard was treated so horribly whereas likewise returning dwelling from a overseas battle, led President Truman to direct the DOJ to maneuver ahead with fees.

Like so many circumstances of its type, a jury in the end acquitted the white officer. However, that acquittal turned the tide and opened the eyes of the federal district choose who presided over the trial. From that day onward, Judge Julius Waties Waring turned an sudden, main participant within the civil rights motion of the 1940s and 1950s. Judge Waring started to take extra circumstances on his docket coping with racial injustice. One such case, Briggs v. Elliott, set in movement a gathering with the NAACP’s prime lawyer, Thurgood Marshall.

According to the PBS documentary, Judge Waring (in an ex parte communication) defined to Marshall that he didn’t need to strive any extra “equalization” circumstances; as an alternative, he needed Marshall to deliver him a lawsuit to function a problem to the constitutionality of segregation as an entire. He satisfied Marshall to dismiss the unique criticism in Briggs and refile the trigger as a problem to Plessy v. Ferguson’s doctrine of “separate but equal,” specializing in the “separate” facet of public education.

Marshall initially misplaced Briggs. As the case made its strategy to the U.S. Supreme Court on appeal, although, it was consolidated with 4 different circumstances, one being Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka. Those 5 circumstances allowed the Supreme Court to overrule Plessy and discover segregation in public colleges unconstitutional.

The result’s a documentary that successfully explains the differing contributions so many individuals made to that closing authorized choice, and the way the start can’t be misplaced on the ends. PBS’s The Blinding of Isaac Woodard reminds how society can change with the assistance of voices loud sufficient to be heard.

Adam Banner

Adam R. Banner is the founder and lead lawyer of the Oklahoma Legal Group, a prison protection regulation agency in Oklahoma City. His follow focuses solely on state and federal prison protection. He represents the accused in opposition to allegations of sex crimes, violent crimes, drug crimes and white-collar crimes.

The research of regulation isn’t for everybody, but its follow and process appears to permeate popular culture at an rising fee. This column is in regards to the intersection of regulation and popular culture in an try and separate the true from the ridiculous.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here