Home Criminal Defense Reflecting On My First In-Person Deposition Since The Shutdown

Reflecting On My First In-Person Deposition Since The Shutdown


As many individuals inside the authorized career perceive from first-hand experience, legal professionals and courts have been conducting operations remotely for the reason that COVID-19 pandemic started. Judges and courtroom attorneys are often holding hearings and conferences by Zoom or different related mediums nowadays to be able to cut back the danger that attorneys and courtroom workers will likely be uncovered to the virus. In addition, many depositions have been held remotely in order that events don’t have to be collectively in a single room through the proceedings. However, I just lately had my first in-person deposition for the reason that pandemic started, and the experience has proven me that there’s much that’s misplaced by holding depositions by distant means.

Rapport Between Attorneys

Of course, a very powerful a part of a deposition is to obtain sworn testament from a witness. However, there are a selection of different the explanation why in-person depositions might be necessary to a case. Perhaps one of the vital necessary features of in-person depositions is that’s will get the entire attorneys linked up to a case in a single room, which might be useful in shifting a case ahead. At an in-person deposition, attorneys can casually discuss discovery disputes, settlement numbers, and quite a few different points whereas everyone seems to be collectively for the aim of taking a deposition. Moreover, attorneys can construct rapport with each other at in-person depositions in methods not potential throughout digital depositions. For occasion, many attorneys eat lunch collectively throughout breaks in a deposition, and this will go a great distance towards constructing connections with different attorneys in your case and even in your apply space. i’ve by no means heard of attorneys consuming their lunches collectively by Zoom throughout digital depositions, and this rapport-building is basically misplaced throughout digital depositions.


One of the most important advantages that I missed about in-person depositions is that taking testament dwell is way extra environment friendly than utilizing Zoom or different distant means. When events use Zoom or different purposes, there may be at all times the danger that internet disruptions and different technical glitches will make it troublesome to take testament. At digital depositions, it is usually generally arduous to listen to folks, and people are much more prone to discuss over one another, which might be troublesome on the deponent, the attorneys, and maybe extra importantly, the courtroom reporter.

Moreover, lots of the procedural elements of a deposition are almost inconceivable when depositions are performed by digital means. For occasion, it’s far more troublesome (or inconceivable) to point out a witness an exhibit throughout a digital deposition, have them learn from a writing, and ask questions pertaining to paperwork and different tangible gadgets. Any good deposition taker will inform you that utilizing displays is a vital a part of directing a witness, and this element of depositions is absolutely arduous with digital proceedings. Moreover, utilizing translators is far simpler in individual than throughout digital depositions. Translators can already add to the time and complexity of a deposition, and that is much more of a problem at digital depositions. All informed, my current experiences with in-person depositions and digital proceedings have proven me that in-person questioning can save each effort and time.

Witness Reactions And Sidebars

Anyone who has participated in a deposition performed over the cellphone and even by Zoom (or the same app) is aware of that it’s arduous to discern witness reactions throughout digital depositions. Being capable of observe the reactions of a witness is extraordinarily necessary to figuring out if a witness is telling the reality, is uncomfortable about sure subjects, and different insights. The reactions can assist inform an legal professional’s perspective, and this can be very troublesome to get this understanding from digital depositions.

In addition, digital depositions make it much simpler for attorneys to teach their shopper throughout a deposition. Some jurisdictions limit the applicability of the attorney-client privilege throughout depositions as a result of courts perceive that it is necessary for witnesses to offer truthful and unguided testament throughout depositions. However, it’s much simpler for attorneys to speak with purchasers with out different counsel realizing about it when they’re in a room collectively and everybody else is collaborating in a continuing remotely. While I don’t need to impugn anybody, everybody is aware of that teaching and different “funny business” typically happens at depositions, and that is much simpler throughout digital depositions.

Of course, i’m not saying that digital depositions shouldn’t happen through the pandemic, and legal professionals — identical to everybody else — must comply with the recommendation of medical professionals. It looks like digital depositions will likely be a much greater a part of the authorized career for a very long time, since well being tips require social distancing and depositions often carry folks collectively. However, my current experiences with each in-person and digital depositions have proven me that digital depositions shouldn’t be an ubiquitous and everlasting fixture of the authorized career.

Jordan Rothman is a companion of The Rothman Law Firm, a full-service New York and New Jersey legislation agency. He can be the founding father of Student Debt Diaries, an Internet site discussing how he paid off his pupil loans. You can reach Jordan by e-mail at jordan@rothmanlawyer.com.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here