Home Criminal Defense Trained canines ought to be allowed to consolation witnesses throughout courtroom proceedings,...

Trained canines ought to be allowed to consolation witnesses throughout courtroom proceedings, ABA House says


ABA Midyear Meeting

Image from Shutterstock.com.

The ABA House of Delegates resolved Monday to assist using skilled canines to consolation susceptible witnesses throughout testament.

Resolution 101A pushes for enacting legal guidelines permitting using canines specifically skilled for aiding witnesses—also called facility canines. The report accompanying the decision contains suggestions to guard the canines’ welfare. The decision, co-sponsored by the International Law Section and the Government and Public Sector Lawyers Division, was handed in a 202-135 vote.

In urging the House to move the decision, Gabrielle M. Buckley of the International Law Section mentioned facility canines would offer “meaningful access to justice” for victims and witnesses who face difficulties testifying in courtroom.

“There is scientific as well as anecdotal evidence that partnering victims with facility dogs can assist in delivering accurate recitation of the facts,” Buckley mentioned.

As of mid-January, 258 facility canines are working in 41 states, in line with the Courthouse Dogs Foundation.

The report accompanying the decision says prior to now 5 years, as many as 15 states have handed legal guidelines allowing using canines to help susceptible witnesses. Some state statutes enable the specifically skilled canines to help kids in abuse and neglect circumstances; different statues let the canines help developmentally disabled adults or witnesses in sexual or home assault circumstances.

Advocates say canines will help ease the minds of traumatized witnesses who concern testifying and assist them specific themselves on the witness stand.

Some protection attorneys argue the canines might have a prejudicial impact on jurors as a result of the presence of a furry pal at a witness’s facet might make them seem extra sympathetic.

Cynthia Orr of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers mentioned Monday that utilizing facility canines was “asking for trouble” and will violate the rights of prison defendants.

“The appearance the witness is entitled to additional support and comfort implies the witness is worthy of belief and of sympathy before they even take the stand,” Orr mentioned. “This puts a thumb on the scales of justice.”

Psychology professor Dawn McQuiston co-authored a paper that explored whether or not facility canines have a prejudicial impact on jurors in mock trials utilizing transcripts and nonetheless photos of canines and witnesses. Though a baby witness showing with a teddy bear appeared to affect jurors in a single experiment, using a canine in two experiments didn’t.

“I don’t believe it’s unreasonable that defense attorneys would be concerned. Our research suggests that defense attorneys don’t need to worry,” McQuiston mentioned in an interview with the ABA Journal, including that analysis on facility canines and prejudice is in its early phases.

A facility canines invoice, the Courthouse Dogs Act, was handed by the U.S. Senate over the last session of Congress, however it was not voted on by the House of Representatives and would should be reintroduced in the course of the 117th Congress. Gregory G. Brooker of the Government and Public Sector Lawyers Division mentioned Monday it was “imperative” the ABA “weigh in on this access-to-justice issue.”

He added that any due course of issues might be addressed in pretrial motions, by way of jury directions previous to testament and earlier than jurors started deliberations.

“I should note that in the 15 jurisdictions that currently authorize courtroom dogs, there have been no due process problems of which I or the committee is aware,” Brooker mentioned.

The decision additionally seeks to guard the canines’ welfare by making certain they’ve correct shelter, breaks and relaxation occasions and lodging are made for every day, long-term care and retirement.

“A facility dog should have a long-term guardian throughout the dog’s lifetime and persons designated to oversee the health and well-being of the dog during the facility service career and in retirement,” the report states.

Follow together with the ABA Journal’s protection of the 2021 ABA Midyear Meeting here.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here